top of page

Have All the Good Ideas Already Been Taken? Why Creativity Isn't About Starting From Scratch

Nov 6
10 min read

Have you ever had an idea that you thought was absolutely brilliant?


You know the feeling.


You're sitting watching television.


Having a shower.


Or perhaps you're just about to fall asleep.


And suddenly something clicks.


“Hang on a minute… that's actually a REALLY good idea!”


You get excited.


You start imagining what it could become.


Perhaps a new game.

A magic trick.

A useful invention.

Or even a business that could change your life.


And then the worst possible thing happens.


You Google it.


And there it is.


Somebody's already done it.


Your moment of genius disappears in approximately three seconds.


Or does it?


Because here's something I've been thinking about.


Have all the good ideas already been taken?


And perhaps more importantly…


Does an idea actually have to be completely original to be brilliant?


The Obsession With Being Completely Original


Here's something I've noticed over the years.


People seem absolutely obsessed with originality.


Everything has to be new.

Different.

Never been done before.


Particularly when it comes to inventing things.


I've seen aspiring creators asking questions such as:


“I've got an idea for a magic trick, but somebody's already made something similar. Should I give up?”


Or:


“I've invented a game, but I've just discovered another game that uses a similar idea. Is there any point continuing?”


My answer?


No. Don't automatically give up.


Because if every inventor abandoned an idea the moment they discovered something similar already existed, we'd have very few new products.


Somebody's Already Invented the Car!


Think about cars.


How many different car manufacturers are there?


They're all essentially making products that do the same basic job.


Four wheels.


A steering wheel.


Some form of engine or motor.


And hopefully something that gets you from A to B without breaking down.


But when a new car comes onto the market, nobody says:


“Hang on! Somebody's already invented the car. You can't do that!”


We look at what makes that particular car different.


Perhaps it's more comfortable.

More efficient.

More affordable.

Safer.

Or simply more enjoyable to drive.


That's what makes the difference.


And I think the same principle applies to games, magic tricks and creative ideas.


Sometimes the most interesting question isn't:


“Has anybody done this before?”


It's:


“Can I do this differently?”


Now that's a much more exciting question.


Magic Has Been Reinventing Ideas for Centuries


As a magician, this is something I find particularly fascinating.


Magicians have been reinventing, adapting and reinterpreting ideas for hundreds of years.


Take one of the simplest plots in card magic.


A spectator selects a card.

The card is lost in the deck.

And somehow the magician finds it.


That's it.


A plot that's probably been performed a billion times.


Possibly more.


But think about how many completely different tricks can be created from that one simple idea.


The card might appear in somebody's pocket.

Inside a sealed envelope.

Underneath someone's chair.

Inside a wallet.

Or perhaps the magician predicts the selected card before the spectator even chooses it.


Maybe the magician never touches the deck at all.


Same underlying premise.


Completely different experiences.


And that word is important.


Experience.


People Remember How You Made Them Feel


I've said this before on the podcast, but I think it's worth repeating.


People don't necessarily remember every technical detail of a magic trick.


They remember how it made them feel.


Were they surprised?

Did they laugh?

Were they completely fooled?

Did they want to see it again?


Did they immediately turn to somebody else and say:


“You've GOT to see this!”


That's what interests me as a creator.


Not simply whether an idea is technically different.


But whether it creates an interesting experience for the person on the receiving end.


And I think there's a lesson here for anyone developing something new.


Don't just focus on what your idea does. Think about how it makes somebody feel.


Creativity Often Means Combining Things That Already Exist


Here's one of my favourite ways of thinking creatively.


Take two things that already exist.


And see what happens when you put them together.


I know.


It sounds ridiculously simple.


But sometimes that's where the magic happens.


Think about a smartphone.


It's a telephone.

A camera.

A music player.

A computer.

A map.

And goodness knows what else.


Most of those individual functions existed long before the modern smartphone.


But combining them into one convenient, accessible device changed the way we use them.


And that same thinking can be applied to almost anything.


What Happens When You Combine Magic, Games and Storytelling?


This is something I explore constantly through Neo Magic and Mind Burp Games.


What happens if you take a traditional card game and introduce a completely different type of decision-making?


What happens if you take a magic trick and introduce a storytelling element?


I'm not talking about Scribble Snap at all here.


Obviously.


Unless you've already seen it!


And what happens if you take a mathematical principle and turn it into something that feels completely impossible?


That last one is particularly close to my heart.


Because I've always been fascinated by the relationship between mathematics and magic.


Mathematics Can Make an Old Idea Feel Brand New


Some of the most baffling magic tricks are built around beautifully simple mathematical principles.


The mathematics itself might have existed for hundreds of years.


But the way you present it can make the effect feel completely fresh.


Perhaps you disguise the principle.

Change the presentation.

Introduce a story.

Or allow the spectator to make all the decisions.


Suddenly something familiar becomes a completely different experience.


That's one of the things I explore in my book Mind the Maths Magic.


And for magicians who enjoy more involved mathematical methods and creative challenges, there's also my book My Head Hurts.


Both are connected to my fascination with taking mathematical ideas and turning them into magical experiences.


So perhaps originality isn't always about inventing something from nothing.


Perhaps it's about discovering an unexpected connection between things that already exist.


Simple Ideas Can Create Extraordinary Reactions


There's another trap I think creative people often fall into.


And I've certainly fallen into it myself.


We assume that if something is simple, it can't possibly be very clever.


So we start adding things.


More rules.

More features.

More components.

More complicated methods.


Before long, our lovely little idea has turned into something that needs a 20-page instruction manual and a degree in advanced engineering.


And I've always been fascinated by simple ideas that produce a disproportionately big reaction.


Something incredibly straightforward that makes people think:


“Wait… WHAT?!”


That's the sort of balance I love.


Why I Prefer Games That Are Easy to Learn


With Mind Burp Games, one of the things I'm interested in creating is games that people can understand relatively quickly.


Because if somebody has to spend 15 minutes learning the rules before they can enjoy themselves, that can become a barrier.


Now, don't get me wrong.


There's absolutely a place for complex strategy games.


And I know there's a huge audience for them.


But there's also something rather wonderful about a game you can explain in a minute or two.


Then spend the next 20 minutes thinking, laughing, competing and enjoying yourself.

And that principle applies well beyond games.


Some of the best presentations, explanations and advertisements take something complicated and make it feel incredibly simple.


The Creative Question Nobody Asks Enough


Here's a question worth asking about your next project.


What could I remove?


Not what could I add.


What could I take away?


What could I remove without losing the thing that makes the idea special?


Sometimes that's where the idea really starts to shine.


And I've experienced that myself with Binary Flip.


What Binary Flip Taught Me About Simplicity


When I created Binary Flip, I started with a very simple concept.


Black and white cards.


Then I introduced action cards to create additional decisions and possibilities.


But something interesting happened as I explored the game.


I realised that even without the action cards, there was an enjoyable game to be played using the basic black and white cards.


The action cards added another dynamic.


But they weren't necessarily the only source of fun.


And that opened up another possibility.


Different ways of playing with the same components.

Different games.

Different experiences.


All starting from one simple idea.


That's something I want to explore further with Binary Flip.


Because sometimes a product has more possibilities than you initially realise.

You just need to look at it differently.


Having an Idea and Doing Something With It Are Very Different Things


Now here's another important point.


Having an idea is exciting.


Actually doing something with it?


That's a completely different story.


I can come up with ideas all day long.


And believe me, I've got hundreds of them.


Some are good.

Some are absolutely rubbish.


And some seem like the greatest invention in human history at eleven o'clock at night.


Only to look completely ridiculous the following morning.


We've all been there.


But that's fine.


Because creativity isn't about every idea being a winner.


It's about being willing to explore ideas and discover which ones are worth developing.


The Problem With Ideas That Only Exist in Your Head


When you're developing a game, there's a huge difference between imagining how enjoyable it will be and actually putting it in front of somebody.


In your head, everything works perfectly.


The rules make sense.


Everyone understands what they're supposed to do.


The players are laughing.


The game flows beautifully.


Then you test it.


And somebody immediately does something you hadn't expected.


Or misunderstands a rule.


Or discovers a way of winning that completely ruins the game.


Brilliant.


Well, perhaps not brilliant at the time.


But actually, it is brilliant.


Because you've learned something.


Your idea is no longer sitting safely inside your head.


It's interacting with the real world.


And that's where improvements happen.


Don't Wait Until Your Idea Is Perfect


This is something I really want to encourage.


Don't wait until your idea is perfect before trying it.


Make a rough version.


Test it.


Let somebody experience it.


And most importantly…


Listen to what they say.


Because sometimes the feedback you initially find frustrating turns out to be the very thing that makes your idea better.


And don't just ask:


“Do you like it?”


Because people often want to be polite.


Particularly friends and family.


They don't want to upset you.


So instead, ask more useful questions.


What was confusing?

Which part did you enjoy most?

Where did you lose interest?

What would you change?

Would you want to play it again?


Those answers can tell you far more than somebody simply saying:


“Yeah, it's really good!”


The Importance of Honest Feedback


There's a useful concept in business called The Mom Test, popularised by Rob Fitzpatrick.


The underlying idea is that you shouldn't rely on people simply telling you your idea is wonderful.


Instead, you should ask questions that help you understand their real experiences, problems and behaviour.


And I think that's particularly useful for creative projects.


Because people can genuinely like you and still give you completely unhelpful feedback.


Sometimes the most valuable person isn't the one who tells you your idea is brilliant.


It's the one who helps you understand why it isn't working yet.


James Dyson and the Power of Prototyping


Here's an example I find fascinating.


James Dyson.


Most of us know the name from vacuum cleaners.


But one of the most interesting parts of his story is the development process.


Dyson famously went through 5,127 prototypes while developing his bagless vacuum cleaner technology.


Five thousand, one hundred and twenty-seven.


Imagine reaching prototype number 4,000 and thinking:


“Do you know what? Perhaps this isn't working.”


I think I'd have needed a very large cup of tea by that point.


But he kept experimenting.


Testing.

Changing things.

Trying again.


And eventually developed a commercially successful product.


Now, the lesson isn't that everybody needs to make thousands of prototypes.


Please don't take that away from this article.


The lesson is that a creative idea often becomes valuable through the work you do after the initial spark.


The Lightbulb Moment Is Only the Beginning


We love celebrating the moment somebody has a brilliant idea.


That sudden flash of inspiration.


The lightbulb moment.


The wonderful feeling when everything clicks.


But what we don't always see is everything that happens afterwards.


The mistakes.

The revisions.

The awkward conversations.

The prototypes that don't work.

The small improvements.


And the decisions that gradually turn something interesting into something genuinely useful.


That's where so much of the real creative work happens.


So the next time you have an idea, don't immediately ask yourself whether it's perfect.


Ask yourself something much more useful.


“Is this worth exploring?”


Because that's a much easier place to begin.


Your Mind Burp Challenge: Become an Inventor in Five Minutes


Right, it's time for this week's Mind Burp Challenge.


And today I want you to become an inventor.


Don't worry.


You don't need a workshop.

You don't need special equipment.

You don't even need to be particularly good at drawing.


All you need is a piece of paper and about five minutes.


Here's what I want you to do.


Choose something ordinary.


It could be:


  • A deck of playing cards

  • A pen

  • A coffee mug

  • A board game

  • A book

  • A rubber band


Anything you like.


Now I want you to ask yourself three questions.


Question 1: What Could I Remove?


Imagine you've chosen a deck of playing cards.

What happens if you remove all the picture cards?

Or all the number cards?

Or perhaps half the deck?

Could you invent a game using what's left?

Could you create a magic trick?

Could removing something make the idea more interesting?


Question 2: What Could I Reverse?


What happens if the person who normally wins a game becomes the loser?

What if the objective isn't to collect something, but to get rid of it?

What if the magician makes a prediction after the spectator has made a decision, yet the result still appears impossible?

Sometimes reversing the usual rules creates an entirely different experience.


Question 3: What Could I Combine It With?


What happens if you combine playing cards with storytelling?

A coffee mug with a puzzle?

A mathematical principle with a magic trick?

A familiar game with a completely different way of winning?

Don't spend ages worrying about whether the ideas are any good.

Just write them down.


Three questions.


Three possible changes.


And hopefully at least one idea that makes you think:


“Hang on… that might actually work!”


That's your challenge.


And if you come up with something interesting, I'd genuinely love to hear about it.


But What If Somebody Has Already Invented My Idea?


Now, before we finish, there's one important distinction I want to make.


Being inspired by an existing idea isn't the same as simply copying somebody else's work.


If you're developing a commercial product, you should research what's already available.


Understand the history.


Check whether relevant intellectual property rights exist.


And give proper credit where it's due.


That's particularly important in magic, where so many methods and principles have been developed and refined over generations.


But discovering something similar doesn't automatically mean you should abandon your idea.


It might mean you need to approach it differently.


Improve it.

Find a different audience.

Or explore a new application.


Inspiration is valuable. Responsible originality matters too.


Have All the Good Ideas Really Been Taken?


So let's return to the question we started with.


Have all the good ideas already been taken?


My answer?


Absolutely not.


I don't think we're even close.


But I do think we sometimes make creativity unnecessarily difficult by convincing ourselves that everything we produce must be completely original.


It doesn't.


An idea can be inspired by something else and still become genuinely worthwhile.


What matters is what you bring to it.


Your experience.

Your perspective.

Your sense of humour.

Your understanding of the people you're creating it for.


And your willingness to keep improving it.


Because sometimes the most exciting ideas aren't created from nothing.


They're created by seeing something familiar in a way nobody else has quite seen before.

And that, for me, is one of the most wonderful things about creativity.


Vinny Sagoo

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page